Rhinoplasty-Open vs Closed

Rhinoplasty-Open vs Closed

If you are concerned about your nose, you should contact a specialist who specializes in cosmetic surgery. The surgeon will then determine whether or not you require rhinoplasty. So, what exactly is rhinoplasty?

Rhinoplasty is a surgical treatment used to change the shape of the nose, which can be done to improve breathing, change the appearance of the nose, or both. Furthermore, the technique has its own sub-techniques that can be used depending on the situation. Namely, the most popular sub techniques are open rhinoplasty and closed rhinoplasty among the other types of nose job. 

As a result, you will consult with a surgeon, if necessary, and he or she will decide whether or not to operate on your nose. 

What is the difference between open and closed rhinoplasty?

By changing the appearance and proportion of your nose, cosmetic nose surgery, also known as rhinoplasty, can improve facial harmony and self-confidence. Cosmetic nose surgery can also improve breathing or correct deformities caused by trauma or a birth condition, as well as change the overall size, tip, bridge, and nostrils of your nose.

It also features sub-techniques, which allow your surgeon to determine how to operate on the target area. Open and closed rhinoplasty, for example, are two of the most popular of these sub-techniques. Of course, they differ in certain ways, but one is not superior to the other; keep this in mind because the only factor that is superior to all others is your needs or your health. 

To begin, open rhinoplasty may be a surgery during which little incision is formed on the columella, the soft tissue that separates the nostrils. This approach allows for simple access to the underlying bone and cartilage structure while under general anesthesia or twilight sedation. The fundamental advantage of the open approach is better accuracy in redesigning the nasal framework to achieve optimum contouring. Because the original structure of the nose has already been altered, the open approach is best used when considering a revision rhinoplasty.

On the other hand, closed rhinoplasty is performed by small incisions which are made entirely hidden within the nostrils. Your surgeon will execute the surgery under general anesthesia or twilight sedation through separate surgical holes in the left and right nostrils. The closed approach is less intrusive and leaves no apparent scarring because there are no exterior incisions.

So, as you may get, the differences between these two methods can be summarized as;

  • Closed approach, which does not require a columellar incision, allows for a speedier operation and less swelling during the recovery period. 
  • An open rhinoplasty, on the other hand, provides for greater precision for problematic noses and when modifying nasal structures in more complex situations.


Which one is less invasive? Open vs Closed Rhinoplasty 

It is very natural to be nervous before any kind of surgery and you may be wondering which technique is less invasive or more suitable for you. But, when it comes to nose job, the answer is ready for you. 

Many surgeons believe that the closed rhinoplasty method is significantly less invasive than open rhinoplasty since the required surgical incisions are made inside the nostrils. The procedure is typically completed faster than open rhinoplasty, and the healing and recuperation period is frequently reduced. Most patients suffer some numbness at the tip of their nose after rhinoplasty, but with closed rhinoplasty, many patients claim that the numbness is barely apparent.

So, the choice will be yours. 

Which one is better for you, open or closed rhinoplasty? 

If you are to get a rhinoplasty, you may be thinking if an open rhinoplasty or a closed rhinoplasty is the best option for you. While these two types differ, deciding between open and closed should not be a top priority in your initial search. The quality and experience of the surgeon you select will have a far bigger impact on the success of your rhinoplasty than whether the procedure is open or closed.

On the other hand, as you may have heard before the practical difference between the two strategies may be minor, but the outcomes are significant. 

The closed approach will give you;

  • Swift operation and less swelling during the recovery period. 
  • Less pain.
  • Less or even no scaring.

To sum up, if you wonder which option is better for you, first you should know that it depends on your own needs and situation. Nevertheless, as the procedure of closed rhinoplasty is accomplished by concealing all necessary incisions within the nostrils by executing the surgery under general anesthesia or twilight sedation through separate surgical holes in the left and right nostril, you may prefer to get it instead of open rhinoplasty. Thus, it would be better for you be close to closed rhinoplasty. 

Which one is cheaper? 

When it comes to monetary issues, nearly everyone just thinks and examines the situation one more time to decide on whether it will be worth it or not, especially if there is one more choice that you can have cheaper.

Nevertheless, the situation here is directly related to your appearance and even your health. So, there should not be any limitation in terms of cash. But, somehow there may be still one more chance. You may examine the situation and the clinic to have a certain pricing. 

Closed rhinoplasty is often more expensive than open nose surgery since it needs more skill and fewer physicians to perform. While an open nose procedure takes longer than a closed nose procedure, the latter is a more sophisticated and rigorous technique that surgeons normally avoid. As a result, some nose surgeons charge a premium for closed rhinoplasty. Nevertheless, you should still be cautious about the prices and do not prefer those clinics which offer you very low and high prices.